Understanding Truck Accident Liability: Determining Fault and Legal Responsibilities

Truck accident liability can be complex, as multiple parties may have contributed to the collision. The following are common factors considered when determining fault.


In most cases, truck accidents occur due to negligence, which refers to the failure to exercise reasonable care that results in harm to others.

Truck Driver

If the truck driver’s actions or inactions led to an accident, they may be found at fault and liable. For example, speeding, distracted driving, fatigue, intoxication, or violating traffic laws.

Trucking Company

Trucking companies can be held liable for accidents caused by their drivers under the legal doctrine of “vicarious liability” or “respondeat superior”. This doctrine holds employers responsible for the actions of their employees within the scope of their employment. In addition, there are instances where a trucking company can be liable for its own negligent actions or inactions, such as failure to perform background checks on drivers or provide adequate training.

Vehicle Maintenance and Inspections

If it is determined that the trucking company or maintenance personnel failed to adequately maintain the vehicle or address known mechanical issues, they may be liable.

Cargo Loading

Improperly loaded or secured cargo can cause a truck to become unstable, leading to collisions. Therefore, the party responsible for cargo loading that leads to an accident can be liable.

Federal Regulations

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) sets standards and regulations that govern trucking operations and are designed to enhance safety on the roads. Violations of these regulations can be strong indicators of negligence and can contribute to liability determination. Some key regulations include:

Hours of Service (HOS)

This law dictates the maximum number of hours a truck driver can operate without taking mandatory rest breaks. Violations of HOS regulations, such as driving while fatigued, can be critical in determining fault for an accident.

Drug and Alcohol Testing

Truck drivers are subject to regular drug and alcohol testing. If a driver is found to be under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time of the accident, it can significantly impact liability.

Vehicle Maintenance

The FMCSA mandates regular inspections and maintenance of commercial trucks. Failure to comply with these regulations can indicate negligence on the part of the trucking company.


determining fault after a truck accident

How Fault is Determined after a Truck Accident

Determining fault after a truck accident involves a thorough investigation of the circumstances surrounding the incident. Here are the steps typically followed to identify the responsible parties:

Accident Scene Investigation

An insurance adjuster or attorney will examine the accident scene through photos, videos, or visiting the scene. They will look at skid marks, debris, location and extent of damage to vehicles, and any other relevant physical evidence.

Eyewitness Accounts

Eyewitness testimony can provide valuable insight into the events leading up to the accident. Statements from drivers, passengers, pedestrians, and anyone else who witnessed the crash help reconstruct the sequence of events and determine potential negligence.

The Police Report

Law enforcement officers who respond to the accident scene will prepare an accident report that includes information about the parties involved, road and weather conditions, statements from witnesses, any citations issued, and the officer’s opinion on the cause of the crash. The report can be critical in determining fault.

Trucking Company Records

The trucking company’s records, including the driver’s logbooks, vehicle maintenance records, and any documentation related to driver training and hiring practices, are analyzed. Violations of federal regulations can be indicators of negligence.

Electronic Data

Many commercial trucks are equipped with electronic data recorders (EDRs) or black boxes. These devices can provide data on the truck’s speed, braking, and other performance metrics leading up to the accident. Analyzing this data can help determine if the truck driver acted negligently.

  • Expert Analysis: In complex cases, experts may be hired. For example, accident reconstruction experts, mechanical engineers, or trucking industry professionals can interpret the evidence and provide insights into the cause of the accident.
  • Compliance with Traffic Laws and Regulations: Violations of traffic laws, such as speeding, running red lights, or improper lane changes, are taken into account.

If you are involved in a truck accident, it is essential to consult an Atlanta truck accident lawyer to ensure your rights are protected, and you receive fair compensation for your injuries and losses.

"When I felt all hope was lost, I contacted Graham Scofield to see if he could represent me. He immediately called me back and thoroughly reviewed with me the case. He was the most patient, kind, sympathetic and the upmost professional attorney throughout the entire process. He was also extremely knowledgeable about the law and was creative when the case worked through the twists and turns. He was also a heck of a fighter for me and got me more settlement than I was expecting. I only wish I called him sooner! Thank you so much Graham, you are an amazing lawyer!!"
Read more testimonials